Your sales are growing, and printing shipping labels has quietly become an unpaid job. If you have narrowed the search to ShippingEasy vs Shippo, both will fix that part: both connect to your store, pull orders in, and print discounted labels without you retyping an address. The choice that lasts is a different question, and it turns on where you sell and what the tool still connects to as your order count climbs. For sellers on Shopify, BigCommerce, WooCommerce or TikTok Shop, that is AfterShip Shipping.
The Short Answer: Shippo vs ShippingEasy vs AfterShip Shipping
Four things decide this for a shop your size: what you pay at your volume, how quickly you can print a first label, which carriers carry discounted rates, and what the tool gives you as you grow.
| Criteria | Shippo | ShippingEasy | AfterShip Shipping |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Free up to 30 labels a month, then Pro by label band, billed monthly or annually | Free up to 25 shipments a month, then paid plans by shipment band, billed monthly | Free plan, 10 labels a month, on the Shopify App Store app; Essentials and Pro by label volume, billed monthly or annually |
| Ease of first use | Connects stores in settings; Etsy orders sync every 15 minutes, eBay hourly | Connects Shopify through its App Store app; lists Amazon, eBay, Etsy and Walmart | Connects directly to Shopify, BigCommerce, WooCommerce and TikTok Shop; other channels by CSV import |
| Discounted rates | USPS, UPS, FedEx and DHL Express discounts on every account | USPS Commercial Pricing and UPS rates through One Balance; own carrier accounts through a monthly add-on | Discounted labels on Essentials, Pro and Enterprise, at rates negotiated by Easyship; merchants can connect their own carrier accounts too |
| Growth path | Tracking pages and notification emails on every plan; custom branding on Pro | Branded tracking on paid plans; four branded delivery emails | AfterShip Tracking: branded tracking page on its free plan, exception and delivery-date notifications on Essentials. AfterShip Returns: self-service returns page. Separate subscriptions |
All three tools have a free plan.
| Labels a month | Shippo | ShippingEasy | AfterShip Shipping |
|---|---|---|---|
| Up to 10 | Free (Starter, up to 30) | Free (Starter, up to 25) | Free, 10 labels (Shopify App Store listing) |
| 11 to 25 | Free | Free | Essentials $11 (100 labels) |
| 26 to 30 | Free | Growth $19.99 | Essentials $11 |
| 31 to 100 | Pro $19 | Growth $19.99 | Essentials $11 |
| 101 to 200 | Pro $19 | Growth $19.99 | Essentials, next stop $23 (300 labels) |
Subscription prices on monthly billing, read on each vendor's pricing page in September 2026; postage is extra. AfterShip Shipping's free plan is published on its Shopify App Store listing.
In a Shopify App Store review, The Keratin Store described using AfterShip Tracking and AfterShip Shipping together:
Their full-service platform works pretty well. Had a great experience with AfterShip Tracking and now I'm enjoying Aftership Shipping as well.
The Keratin Store, Shopify App Store review, 15 September 2023
Head-to-Head: ShippingEasy vs. Shippo on What Matters
Three questions settle most of this at your volume: what the plan costs where you actually ship, how long it takes to get a first label out the door, and whether your sales channels feed orders in without retyping.
Pricing and discounted rates. Shippo's help centre documents a free Starter plan and a Pro plan priced by label band, billed monthly or annually. Shippo's free plan covers up to 30 labels a month. ShippingEasy's plan overview documents a free plan up to 25 shipments a month, then a Growth plan and higher plans priced by shipment band, billed monthly. Both vendors' figures sit in the table above.
The discount routes differ:
- Shippo's help centre documents USPS, UPS, FedEx and DHL Express discounts that are active on every account.
- ShippingEasy's plan overview includes USPS Commercial Pricing and UPS rates through One Balance on all plans, with your own carrier accounts available through a monthly add-on.
USPS publishes Retail and Commercial prices, and its business pricing page explains the difference. Both tools apply their discounts on every plan, so the carriers you ship with most decide which list matters to you.
Ease of use. Shippo connects a store from its settings, and its help centre documents Etsy orders syncing as often as every 15 minutes and eBay hourly. ShippingEasy connects Shopify through its Shopify App Store app, and that listing names Amazon, eBay, Etsy and Walmart among the channels it works with.
Core integrations. For a Shopify store, the shippo vs shippingeasy shopify question is whether orders arrive without retyping them. Both connect to Shopify directly. On Etsy, Shippo's help centre documents Etsy order syncing, and ShippingEasy's help centre documents an Etsy order import. ShippingEasy adds customer marketing tools to shipping, except for Etsy stores.
If Etsy is your main channel, read Etsy's own help centre first: it lists which third-party shipping apps automatically import and export shipping data for US sellers. If most of your volume sits on Shopify instead, other Shopify shipping tools are worth a look before you commit.
The thing to weigh next is where you sell today, and what the tool still connects to when your order count doubles.
The Hidden Ceiling: What Changes as Your Order Count Grows
Nothing breaks when your order count climbs. What changes is where your time goes: more "where is my order?" emails, more return requests typed out by hand, and more shipments that go wrong on a route you would not have chosen. One thing sits underneath two of the three shifts below. AfterShip's tracking data feeds both the delivery notifications and the carrier recommendation, and the recommendation explains why it picked each service rather than reporting the outcome after the parcel has already gone.
The first shift lands in your inbox. Both tools already send shipment notification emails: Shippo's help centre documents order notification emails on every plan, and ShippingEasy documents four branded moments (label created, estimated delivery date, out for delivery and delivered). AfterShip Tracking, on its Essentials plan, also sends a notification when a shipment's sub-status or its estimated delivery date changes. AfterShip Tracking is its own subscription, as is AfterShip Returns.
StackCommerce reduced WISMO tickets by 71% using AfterShip Tracking.
The second shift is the return pile. Shippo's and ShippingEasy's help centres both document return labels the merchant creates, so the label itself is handled. AfterShip Returns adds a branded returns page on its Essentials plan, one that shoppers start themselves.
The third shift shows up in your exception rate. AfterShip Shipping's Smart Carrier Recommendation is available on all plans and stays off until you switch it on. It screens out services with a high exception rate for that shipment's origin and destination, using AfterShip tracking data, and shows you the reasoning behind each service it recommends.
Start with the label. Add AfterShip Tracking or AfterShip Returns when notifications or returns start taking up your week.
AfterShip Shipping: The Platform That Grows With You
Whatever else it does, a shipping tool has to print a label. AfterShip Shipping connects directly to Shopify, BigCommerce, WooCommerce and TikTok Shop, and when you create a label it compares shipping rates and delivery times across services so you can weigh cost against speed in the same view. AfterShip Shipping is designed to scale with your business's growth.
Its product page puts the carrier network at 130+ carriers in one integration. Discounted labels come with the Essentials, Pro and Enterprise plans, at rates negotiated by Easyship, AfterShip's shipping partner. If you have carrier accounts of your own, you can connect those as well. Two further reads go deeper: a detailed look at AfterShip vs. Shippo for the direct comparison, and a walkthrough of how to compare shipping rates if you would rather start with the mechanics.
There is one thing to know before you commit. If you sell mainly on Etsy or eBay, AfterShip Shipping takes those orders by CSV file rather than a direct connection. On Shopify, BigCommerce, WooCommerce, or TikTok Shop it connects directly, and AfterShip Tracking and AfterShip Returns can be added later as separate subscriptions.
If you sell on one of those four platforms, that makes AfterShip Shipping practical shipping software for small business now, with room to add tracking and returns later. Smart Carrier Recommendation is available on every plan, so you can switch it on from your first label.
Beyond the Label: What Shipping, Tracking, and Returns Do Together
Once a parcel leaves your table, what your customer sees is no longer the label. It is the tracking page, the update in their inbox, and the return flow if the size was wrong. The first two run on AfterShip tracking data.
AfterShip Shipping syncs the shipments you label into AfterShip Tracking, which needs its own active Tracking subscription to receive them. On the Tracking side, the free plan already includes a branded tracking page, and the sub-status and revised delivery date notifications covered above begin on Essentials.
That same AfterShip tracking data feeds the carrier recommendation described above.
AfterShip runs these as one suite: shipping, tracking, returns, and warranty. A small shop can start with shipping and add tracking or returns when each is worth the time.
Final Verdict: Which Shipping Software Should You Choose?
Shippo, ShippingEasy and AfterShip Shipping all print discounted labels. The difference shows up once delivery performance starts to matter, to your customers and to your calendar. For a small shop selling on AfterShip Shipping's directly connected store platforms, AfterShip Shipping is the specialist choice at that point.
On economics, each tool publishes its plans and prices in the table above. Price them against the volume you actually ship.
Where Shippo or ShippingEasy fits:
- Shippo: multi-carrier discounts on a free plan up to 30 labels a month, then a Pro plan priced by volume.
- ShippingEasy: a free plan up to 25 shipments a month, branded tracking from its first paid plan, and a customer marketing module for most store platforms.
Where AfterShip Shipping fits:
- You sell on Shopify, BigCommerce, WooCommerce or TikTok Shop and want a direct store connection.
- You want carrier recommendations that screen services on exception rates from AfterShip tracking data and explain each pick (Smart Carrier Recommendation, on all plans).
- You expect to add exception and delivery-date notifications (AfterShip Tracking, fed by the shipments you label) or a returns page shoppers start themselves (AfterShip Returns), each a separate subscription, within one suite: shipping, tracking, returns, and warranty.
If you would rather place all three against the wider market before deciding, there is a guide to the broader shipping software landscape.
Simplify shipping and order fulfillment across Shopify, TikTok Shop, and your carrier network.
Book a demoShipping Software FAQ
How do Shippo and ShippingEasy pricing compare at 100 shipments a month?
At 100 shipments a month you are past both free plans, so Shippo Pro and ShippingEasy Growth are the tiers in play, and both vendors publish their monthly prices in the pricing table above. AfterShip Shipping covers 100 labels a month on its Essentials plan. For shippingeasy vs shippo pricing at this volume, see the 31 to 100 row of the table.
Does AfterShip have a free plan?
Yes, 10 shipping labels a month on the free plan of the AfterShip Shipping + Labels app on the Shopify App Store. Paid plans begin at Essentials once you pass that allowance.
What's the best shipping software for Etsy sellers?
An Etsy seller mainly needs orders to reach the shipping tool without retyping them. Etsy states that for US sellers, Shippo and ShipStation are the only third-party shipping apps that automatically import and export shipping data with an Etsy shop. AfterShip Shipping takes Etsy orders by CSV import, and if you later add a Shopify, BigCommerce, WooCommerce or TikTok Shop store, that is the natural point to bring it in. Start from how your orders arrive today, and the right tool for an Etsy shop follows from that.
Can I start with AfterShip Shipping and add tracking and returns later?
Yes. AfterShip Tracking and AfterShip Returns are separate subscriptions from AfterShip Shipping, so you can add either one when it earns its place. Syncing the shipments you label into Tracking needs an active Tracking subscription, and Tracking's free plan already includes a branded tracking page. You can start with labels today and add the customer-facing side as your order count grows.
